Your Guide to Understanding Amazon 1P vs 3P

The decision between becoming an Amazon 1P vendor or 3P seller can dramatically impact your business's profitability, control, and growth potential. Many business owners struggle with understanding the key differences between Amazon 1P vs 3P models and which approach aligns best with their long-term goals.

Whether you're just launching on Amazon or reconsidering your current selling strategy, this comprehensive guide will help you navigate the complexities of Amazon's selling models. We'll explore the fundamental differences between first-party sellers and third-party sellers, examine the pros and cons of each approach, and explain how All Points' FBA Prep services can help optimize your Amazon business regardless of which path you choose.

What Are Amazon 1P and 3P?

The Amazon 1P (first-party) model means you operate as a wholesale supplier to Amazon. As a 1P vendor, you sell your products directly to Amazon, who then resells them to customers. This wholesale relationship means Amazon purchases your inventory outright through purchase orders, takes ownership of the goods, and handles the entire retail process—from pricing and marketing to shipping and customer service.

Amazon 1P vendors manage their business through Vendor Central, Amazon's portal for wholesale suppliers. Through Vendor Central, you'll receive purchase orders from Amazon, manage payments, and handle various operational aspects of your vendor relationship.

In the Amazon 3P (third-party) model, you're not selling to Amazon but rather selling directly to customers through the Amazon marketplace. As a third-party seller, you maintain ownership of your inventory and have more control over how your products are marketed and sold.

Third-party sellers operate through Seller Central, Amazon's platform for marketplace sellers. Your Seller Central account gives you tools to create and manage product listings, set prices, fulfill orders, and track sales performance. The 3P model gives you greater control but also comes with more responsibility for managing the entire selling process.

Key Differences Between Amazon 1P vs 3P

Understanding the fundamental differences between these two selling models is crucial for making an informed decision about which path is right for your business. Below, we've broken down how each approach differs in some key characteristics.

How to Identify Which Model You're Using

If you're already selling on Amazon but aren't sure which model you're using, here's a simple way to identify your current status:

You're a 1P Vendor if:

• You receive purchase orders from Amazon
• You log in to Vendor Central to manage your business
• Amazon buys your products at a wholesale price
• Amazon controls the retail pricing of your products
• You ship inventory to Amazon in response to their orders
• Your products show as "Ships from and sold by Amazon.com"

You're a 3P Seller if:

• You manage your own Amazon Seller Central account
• You set your own retail prices in the Amazon marketplace
• You decide when and how much inventory to send to Amazon (if using FBA)
• You pay referral fees to Amazon on each sale
• Your products show as "Sold by [Your Business Name]"
• You have access to some customer information

Pros and Cons of the 1P Model

Becoming an Amazon vendor comes with a distinct set of trade-offs. While Amazon's massive reach and infrastructure can supercharge your sales volume, you'll need to decide if relinquishing control is worth the potential gains. Below, we've given you a quick look at what makes the 1P path attractive—and what might give you pause before signing that vendor agreement.

Pros and Cons of the 3P Model

Taking the reins as a third-party seller puts you squarely in the driver's seat of your Amazon business. With greater control comes greater responsibility—and potentially greater rewards. Here's what awaits businesses brave enough to navigate the Amazon marketplace on their own terms.

Hybrid Approaches: Can You Do Both?

It isn't always a competition of Amazon 1P vs 3P, though. Some businesses successfully operate hybrid models, using both 1P and 3P channels to get the most out of the Amazon marketplace. This approach can leverage the advantages of each model while mitigating their respective drawbacks.

For example, you might:

• Sell high-volume, established products through Amazon Vendor Central
• Keep newer or higher-margin products under your control in Seller Central
• Use your Amazon seller account for products they aren't interested in purchasing wholesale

However, managing both channels simultaneously comes with challenges, including:

• Maintaining price parity to avoid competition between your own listings
• Additional administrative overhead of managing both Vendor Central and Seller Central
• Potentially confusing customer experience if the same products appear under different sellers

Making the Right Choice for Your Business

When deciding between Amazon 1P vs 3P, consider these key questions:

What are your margin requirements? If maintaining higher profit margins is essential, the 3P model likely offers better opportunities. If you're focused on volume and simplicity, 1P might be more appropriate.

How important is pricing control? If consistent pricing across all sales channels is crucial for your brand, the 3P model provides the control you need.

What are your operational capabilities? The 3P model requires more hands-on management of the selling process. Do you have the resources and expertise to handle this effectively?

What are your growth goals? Consider which model better aligns with your long-term business objectives and scalability plans.

Different industries and product types may be better suited to particular models. For example:

• High-margin, branded products often perform better under the 3P model
• Commodity products with thin margins might benefit from the volume of the Amazon 1P model
• Products requiring special handling or customer education may perform better when you control the listings as a 3P seller

Optimizing Your Amazon 1P or 3P Strategy

Regardless of which model you choose, certain best practices can help maximize your success:

For 1P Vendors:

• Negotiate favorable terms with Amazon, including wholesale prices and marketing support
• Maintain consistent inventory availability to meet Amazon's purchase orders
• Develop strong forecasting capabilities to anticipate Amazon's ordering patterns
• Ensure strict compliance with Amazon's packaging and shipping requirements to avoid chargebacks
• Regularly review your product listings to ensure accurate information

For 3P Sellers:

• Optimize your product listings with high-quality images, detailed descriptions, and relevant keywords
• Maintain healthy inventory levels to prevent stockouts
• Monitor and respond to customer feedback to maintain positive ratings
• Consider using FBA for popular products to leverage Prime eligibility
• Stay informed about Amazon's policies and performance requirements

If any of that sounds overwhelming, you're in luck. Third party selling has never been easier now that third party logistics providers (3PLs) are offering a range of Amazon prep services. All Points is happy to offer these services to their clients to allow them to tap into Amazon's vast customer base with less overhead.

‍

How All Points FBA Prep Services Help Both 1P and 3P Sellers

Whether you're operating as a 1P vendor or 3P seller, All Points' specialized Amazon seller services can streamline your Amazon operations and help you avoid costly mistakes.

For 1P Vendors:

Purchase Order Management: We help you efficiently process and fulfill Amazon's purchase orders, ensuring timely delivery to their fulfillment centers.

Compliance Expertise: Our team understands Amazon's strict vendor requirements, reducing the risk of chargebacks for non-compliance.

Packaging and Labeling: We ensure all products meet Amazon's specifications for packaging, labeling, and shipping, preventing delays and penalties.

Quality Control: Our thorough inspection process catches potential issues before products reach Amazon, protecting your vendor relationship.

For 3P Vendors:

Optimized FBA Prep: We prepare your inventory according to Amazon's guidelines, minimizing the risk of complications or additional fees.

Inventory Management: Our systems help you maintain optimal inventory levels across multiple sales channels, reducing the risk of stockouts or excess inventory.

Scalable Operations: During peak seasons or growth periods, our capacity expands to meet your needs without compromising quality.

Cost Efficiency: Our expertise in Amazon's requirements helps minimize fees and maximize your profit margins.

‍